Owners access | Unofficial spa resort booking and information site
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island Heights
596US$
Book with us and save
up to 10%
compared to Booking.com
Key details
About Resort
35 Shore Rd,
Shelter Island Heights,
New York,
United States of America,
11965,
New York State
Sunset Beach, a 4-star pet-friendly hotel, is a romantic seaside hideaway nestled on Shelter Island's most idyllic beach. It features modern rooms with hardwood floors and offers various amenities including free Wi-Fi and bicycle rentals.
Rooms & Amenities
Each modern room at Sunset Beach is equipped with an iPod docking station, a flat-screen LCD TV, and a DVD player. Guests can enjoy bay views from the private terrace available in select rooms. The property also features grooming services for pets.
Dining Options
Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar serves French cuisine in a casual atmosphere and offers a full-service bar with a curated wine list. Guests can relax at the private beach after dining.
Leisure Activities
Guests can explore the island with free bicycle rentals or relax on the private beach. Yoga sessions and in-room massages are available at Sunset Beach.
Transportation & Location
Sunset Beach is accessible via ferry service from both the North and South Forks of Long Island. This Shelter Island Heights hotel ensures convenient access for guests traveling from Long Island MacArthur, located 52.5 miles away.
View all
Select your room type
The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
Explore a range of transportation options for your spa getaway
City Center
Shelter Island Heights400 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP)
52.5
mi
Republic (FRG)
70.2
mi
Facilities
The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Delicious Cocktails!
“The cocktails at Sunset Beach were excellent, especially the unique Summer Fling cocktail that made for a refreshing beachside treat.” view full review
Charming Rustic Decor
“The room decor had a quaint, rustic charm that truly contributed to the beach getaway vibe, making it feel cozy and inviting.” view full review
Fun Atmosphere!
“The lively atmosphere during summer weekend nights with a DJ spinning after sunset elevated our experience and made it a perfect party spot.” view full review
Thoughtful Touch!
“The surprise continental breakfast hamper delivered to our room was a good start to our beach day, even if it wasn't my favorite food.” view full review
General
Wi-Fi
Smoke detectors
Dining
Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area
Room features
Dressing area
Ironing facilities
Bathroom
Hair dryer
Media
Flat-screen TV
Direct dial telephone
CD player
AM/FM alarm clock
Room decor
Carpeted floor
Show more
Location
35 Shore Rd,
Shelter Island Heights,
New York,
United States of America,
11965,
New York State
Map view
35 Shore Rd,
Shelter Island Heights,
New York,
United States of America,
11965,
New York State
City landmarks
Shelter Island Country Club
2300 ft
Golf Course
Shelter Island Golf Course
2400 ft
Shelter Island Tennis Club
3000 ft
Events
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
1.4
mi
Church
Our Lady of the Isle Church
4000 ft
Dering Harbor Marina
1.4
mi
Amusement Park
Greenport Antique Carousel
2.0
mi
Island
Shelter Island
1.5
mi
Sylvester Manor
1.4
mi
440 4th St at the LIRR Tracks
Railroad Museum of Long Island
1.8
mi
Wiggins St Greenport Commercial Pier
Fireboat Firefighter Museum
1.8
mi
519 4th St
Congregation Tifereth Israel
1.9
mi
Market
The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor
1.4
mi
Front Street Mitchell Park
Camera Obscura
1.9
mi
Museums
East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation
1.8
mi
Church
Shelter Island Presbyterian Church
1.5
mi
3rd St
East End Seaport Maritime Museum
2.2
mi
Gallery
Nova Constellatio Gallery
2.1
mi
Manhansett Chapel Museum
1.7
mi
Harbor
Greenport
2.1
mi
Fire Fighter Ship New York
1.8
mi
Shelter Island Whale's Tail
1.7
mi
Church
Saint Marys Episcopal Church
1.8
mi
Long Island Train Museam
1.8
mi
Greenport Theatre
1.9
mi
Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church
1.9
mi
Museums
Havens House
1.9
mi
Gallery
VSOP Art + Design Projects
1.9
mi
Nearby
Sunset Beach
800 ft
Beach
Crescent Beach
1800 ft
Restaurants
The Pridwin Restaurant
3000 ft
81 Shore Road
Reviews and Ratings
<br />
Feedback from previous guests about their experience.
78%
loved the resort and would return for another relaxing stay
Beautiful beach access
Attentive beach staff
Room quality
Limited dining options
7.8/10
Very good
Rooms
5.0
Location
7.2
Service
5.0
Dining
5.0
Guest reviews
7.8/10
based on 5 reviews
8.2
8.2/10 based on 8 reviews
Steve
United States of America,
March
2025
5.0/10
My experience at Sunset Beach was a mix of fun and frustration. The overall vibe was lively, especially during weekends, which I liked, but the hotel itself needed serious improvements. The check-in process was a bit chaotic, and I left feeling disappointed by the disheveled condition of the rooms and the lack of dining options. There’s potential, but right now it feels off balance.
Rooms
5.0
The rooms were rustic and appeared neglected, with some maintenance issues that were hard to overlook.
Service
5.0
Service was unfortunately dismissive and unhelpful at times, leaving a lot to be desired.
Location
6.0
The location has charm but is plagued by parking issues that complicated our arrival.
Dining
5.0
Dining was an odd experience. The food was okay, but the prices felt steep for what we got, and the options were limited.
Facilities
5.0
The facilities seemed outdated and were not well-maintained, diminishing the overall experience.
Curtis
United States of America,
December
2024
5.0/10
Sunset Beach has a lively atmosphere and is located in a beautiful area of Shelter Island. However, my experience was marred by inconsistent service and dining availability. The rooms left a lot to be desired, feeling rustic and in need of updates. Given the price point, I expected more in terms of both service and comfort.
Rooms
5.0
The rooms were somewhat rustic and in disrepair, lacking modern amenities.
Service
5.0
Service varied; while some staff were friendly, others were unhelpful, especially during dining hours.
Location
7.0
Located near a lovely beach, but access issues can be frustrating, especially with parking.
Dining
5.0
Dining options were quite limited, with many closures during our stay, leaving us hungry at times.
Facilities
5.0
The facilities seem to focus more on the bar scene rather than on providing a well-rounded hotel experience.
Claire
United States of America,
November
2024
6.0/10
Sunset Beach has its charm with a relaxing atmosphere and friendly beach staff, but it also comes with some significant drawbacks. The rooms feel a bit outdated and need maintenance, and the dining options are quite limited, which can leave you frustrated. The location is beautiful, and the beach is lovely, but it might not be worth the price you pay for what you actually get.
Rooms
5.0
The rooms are not super luxe and have a slightly rustic feel. They could definitely use some updates and better maintenance.
Service
7.0
The manager was responsive to complaints during our stay, helping us when the restaurant was closed and arranging a food delivery.
Location
8.0
The scenic beauty of Shelter Island is simply breathtaking, adding charm to the hotel experience, but it might not be easily accessible without a car.
Dining
5.0
Dining at the hotel was quite disappointing, with limited hours and an inconvenient closure schedule for the restaurant.
Facilities
6.0
The beach and outdoor facilities are inviting but overall, the hotel lacks some crucial amenities for a more comfortable stay.
Robert
United States of America,
November
2024
5.6/10
My recent stay at Sunset Beach Hotel was quite the mixed bag. The location is beautiful and the beach staff are truly wonderful, but the service and amenities left a lot to be desired. The room comfort was lacking, and I felt the dining options were pretty poor considering the price I paid. Overall, it has a charming vibe, but it feels more like a motel than a resort spa.
Rooms
5.0
The rooms were minimal and felt a bit rustic, definitely not the luxurious resort vibe I was hoping for.
Service
6.0
While the manager was responsive to my complaints, the overall service seemed disorganized, especially with the lack of food options.
Location
8.0
Shelter Island is absolutely beautiful, and the hotel has lovely access to the beach, which is a major plus.
Dining
5.0
Dining was quite disappointing, with the restaurant closed on Tuesdays and limited options for breakfast.
Facilities
5.0
The hotel had a laid-back atmosphere, which I appreciated, but it really needs some investment in both the rooms and dining facilities.
Beautiful beach access
Room quality
Paul
United States of America,
October
2024
5.0/10
I had high hopes for Sunset Beach, given its vibrant scene and stunning location on Shelter Island. However, my experience was overshadowed by service issues and a lack of attention to detail. The atmosphere was party-centric, which might appeal to some, but I found it lacking in the quality and service I'd expect from a resort-like this. While I appreciated the beauty of the setting, I'd suggest seeking other options for a more consistent experience.
Rooms
5.0
The overall condition of the rooms has noticeably declined over the years, with several maintenance issues like a malfunctioning refrigerator and dirty rugs.
Service
5.0
While I encountered some helpful staff at check-in, the overall service felt unfriendly and inattentive, especially when it came to room cleaning and requests for basic amenities.
Location
7.0
The hotel is located in a beautiful area of Shelter Island, but the access to parking can be confusing and inconvenient, as I had to park further down the street with our reservation.
Dining
5.0
Dining was overpriced for the quality offered. While the cocktails were enjoyable, the overall food experience did not live up to my expectations, and breakfast was nonexistent during my visit.
Facilities
5.0
Facilities seem to have fewer amenities than what used to be offered, like the absence of breakfast service and limited operational hours for the restaurant.
Want to see exclusive early booking offers?
Access special rates now and plan your next wellness retreat!
Thunderbird Beach Resort
All Seasons Resort
Fountain Point
Savannah Beach
Franklyn D Resort & Spa All Inclusive
The Meridian Club, Turks And Caicos
Jumeirah Dar Al Masyaf Dubai
Aston Paki Maui
Laluna Boutique Hotel & Villas
Lake Of The Springs Camping Resort Yurt 1
Madison Resort Wildwood Crest
El Beso Adults Only At Ocean Riviera Paradise All Inclusive